Multiemployer Pension Rescue Proposal Released

November 22, 2019

Senate Finance Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-IA) and Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee Chairman Lamar Alexander (R-TN) released their comprehensive multiemployer pension reform proposal on November 20, 2019. Summarized in a white paper and technical explanation entitled “Multiemployer Pension Recapitalization and Reform Plan” (MPRRP). The proposal is a comprehensive and complicated re-write of the multiemployer plan rules as compared with current law and reflects a yeoman’s job of Congressional staff over recent years working diligently to get this latest reform done right from their perspectives. Still, that ultimate judgment in the near term will depend on intense negotiations among the various stakeholders on a final proposal that may be okayed by Congressional leadership for enactment on the year-end spending measure in late December – if equitable compromises on both sides of the aisle can be reached on the crucial principal issues.

1) Plans eligible for PBGC partition – Significantly increased PBGC premium levies on all plans, combined perhaps with some as-yet-to-be-defined amount of government appropriations support, will be dedicated to finance and administer a robust PBGC partition program, to pay some of the benefits of “orphans” (participants whose employers no longer contribute to the plans) in qualifying critical and declining plans that meet specific criteria, along with three qualifying named exceptional plans: Teamsters Central States, Road Carrier Local 707, and the United Mineworkers National plan. As proposed, partition payments from PBGC are greater for Central States and Road Local 707 as compared with other eligible partitioned plans. The PBGC maximum payment guaranty would be increased from $12,870 per year, to approximately $20,000 annually.

2) PBGC premium increases – The PBGC premium increases proposed are comprised of the following elements:

  • Flat rate increase – The flat rate per participant annual per capita payment would increase, rising from the current $29 per person per year to $80 per person per year (the same as the single employer plan premium now).
  • New variable rate premiums – A new variable rate premium is added, amounting to 1% of a plan’s current unfunded liability divided by the number of participants, capped at $250 per person per year.
  • New stakeholder retiree, union, and participating employer monthly “co-pays” – The proposal adds new “co-payments” on unions and employers amounting to $2.50 per participant per month, and on retiree benefits levied (collected by monthly plan withholding on a sliding scale based on plan funding status), ranging from a low of 3% for retirees in critical plans, to up to 10% for retirees in partitioned plans.

3) Funding rules – mandated assumed discount rate valuation of liabilities – The proposal requires that the assumed discount rate used by actuaries to project plan liabilities be limited to the lesser of either 6% or the 24-month average third-segment of the 25-year corporate bond yield curve, plus 2%. Experts comment that in most instances the lesser rate will be 6%. This rate is to be phased in over five years, beginning in Plan Year 2020. Changes in plans’ funding status due solely to the decreased interest rate assumption may amortized over 30 years.

4) Changes to withdrawal liability rules – The construction industry basic withdrawal liability rules and exemption remain intact. However, the methods for measuring maximum annual payments for any liability incurred are changed materially. The 10-year look back for maximum annual payment calculation is extend to 20 years, and the period of payment of liability is gauged by plan funding status. Plans are required to provide withdrawal liability estimates to all contributing employers free of charge every three years.

There are a myriad of other significant changes in the MPRRP proposal, including zone status rule changes. MCAA is analyzing the changes in conjunction with our consultants at Horizon Actuarial Services and Groom Law Group, along with our stakeholder partners at the UA.

Other stakeholder coalitions, including the NCCMP and the Construction Employers of America (CEA), are engaged in similar in-depth assessments and analysis in preparation for the key negotiation period between now and Congressional recess in late December.

All recognize that successful reforms this year are key, as a general election year is usually not conducive to delicate bipartisan compromises on crucial national issues. However, it also is widely recognized that significant equitable compromises in the initial proposal are essential to avoid further destabilizing the entire multiemployer system to provide partition for only a relatively small yet very significant subset of the whole.

MCAA’s leadership is taking this very important matter under advisement and will keep you apprised of developments along the way to whatever resolution may be achieved by the end of the year.

White Paper Summary

Technical Explanation

Related Articles
In March, as a majority of the country slowed down, the MCAA Government Affairs Committee continued to work tirelessly meeting with countless Congressional and Senate office’s remotely to push our agenda forward. The committee has been working on COVID-19 cost increases on Federal projects, change orders in the NDAA, pension issues, and the PBGC just to mention a few.…
As the new Senate bill was passed by the House on April 23, 2020, the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) gained additional emergency funds. MCAA partners and law firm, Lindabury, McCormick, Estabrook & Cooper, P.C., provide an overview of the program application and loan forgiveness requirements to assist MCAA members.…
The Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) requires certain employers to provide their employees with paid sick leave or expanded family and medical leave for specified reasons related to COVID-19. The Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division administers and enforces the new law’s paid leave requirements. These provisions are effective on April 1, 2020, and apply to leave taken through December 31, 2020.…
The Department of Labor has provided guidance explaining the Paid Sick Leave and Expanded Family Medical Leave under the Families First Coronavirus Response Act. Please note questions 35-37 deal with Multiemployer CBAs but still need more clarification.…

Join John and Kip Bagley (SVP of Service, EMCOR Services Mesa Energy Systems) on Friday, August 14 at 2 p.m. EDT as they discuss how the circumstances of 2020 have impacted recruitment, perception of the industry, and what it means to be of service. http://ow.ly/jgEw50ATQso

Be the FIRST to receive the 2020 #ConTechReport by giving us 15 minutes to participate in the #2020ConTechSurvey! https://jbk.fyi/MCAA

The UA is offering a free program for all MCAA contractors and UA members on navigating plumbing service calls through a holistic approach. Join them on August 26, from 10 AM – 12 PM EDT.

http://ow.ly/bnqd50AMKfm

Make sure your techs have the up-to-date safety training they need to protect themselves by registering for MCAA/MSCA's next Qualified Level Arc Flash Safety Training webinars on August 20! Register now for MCAA member discount pricing! Learn more at http://ow.ly/5bM650ASurZ

Load More...