2019 MSCA Benchmark Survey Results

October 28, 2019

MSCA conducted a comprehensive benchmark survey to obtain data on key performance indicators (KPIs) in the HVACR and plumbing service industry. The results were very insightful and sure to be beneficial to all MSCA members. The full report is now available, results are presented in two formats, one is overall results and the second is broken down by company size which can provide specific insight relevant to your company. In addition, the findings have been summarized below.

Features of BEST in CLASS Contractors

• Provide primarily air conditioning, heating, plumbing & controls services
• Focused on growing their service agreement base
• Have a separate P/L for service and construction
• Have dedicated service agreement sales personnel
• Bill service agreements in advance
• “Auto Increase” service agreements at renewal (1-3% most common)
• Service Agreement (PM) retention rate of 96% or greater
• Bill quickly – Average is 4–7 days (upon completion of work)
• Track monthly sales to monthly sales goals
• 66% of contractors average $300,000 or more revenue per service vehicle
• Allow service technicians to quote work in the field (average limit is approximately $6,000)
• Hire salespeople from the field
• Annual scheduled preventative maintenance hours per service technician between 300 and 800
• Provide 1 to 50 hours of technical and safety training per year per technician
• Provide training for new service sales reps
• Have an average ratio of 2 to 3 field techs to one office staff
• Total non-billable technician time between 5-10% annually
• Truck inventory tracked using a software system
• Replace service vans based on mileage (100K-150K miles most common)
• Use some form of social media (most common are LinkedIn #1, Facebook #2, Twitter #3)
• Have deployed a mobile field solution
• Have implemented measures to avoid a data breach

AH-HA Revelations from 2019 MSCA Benchmark Survey

• 32% of companies have not deployed a mobile solution
• Over 50% of contractors do not have automatic renewal of PMs
• 37% of companies auto-renewing at an increase of 1% – 3% – are they keeping up with costs?
• 52% of companies missing out on a cash flow opportunity by not advance billing their service contracts
• 33% of companies do not track truck inventory
• 30% of contractors do not have a separate P/L for service – how do they know how they are performing?
• 56% of companies allow service techs to quote jobs in the field (from $500 – $25,000)
• Since 2015, 4% increase in those companies offering plumbing service, 5% increase in those performing refrigeration work and 7% increase in residential work
• Since 2015, there was a 10% decline in the number of companies performing controls work, building controls systems integration work, building operations and testing and balancing
• Annual service projects revenue grew from $1 – $3 million to over $5 million
• 88% of contractors have less than 20% non-billable time
• Contractors replacing vans more frequently than in 2015 – 72% replace every five years or less
• 41% of companies with dedicated maintenance sales personnel sell over $300,000 new service agreements annually compared to all other companies where only 24% average over $300,000 in service agreement sales per rep
• 75% of companies still tracking tools manually or not at all
• 25% of companies have experienced a cyber-security breach
• 27% of companies use SEO and have seen a 5 – 10% increase in traffic
• 72% of contractors do not have a sales training program
• 20% of companies take more than 15 days to bill once job complete
• 40% of companies do NOT track monthly sales against monthly sales goals
• 68% of companies do not employ dedicated maintenance sales personnel
• 30% of companies use no social media

Related Articles
Following an energy audit, McKinstry specified Uponor’s flexible Ecoflex preinsulated piping to resolve a remote Minnesota school’s longtime heating problems and save the school thousands in energy costs. Ecoflex proved easy to install, allowing workers to lay hundreds of feet of piping in just one week.…
MCAA’s Virtual Trade Show connects our contractor members with the members of MCAA’s Manufacturer/Supplier Council.…
Prefabrication was just one of the ways that Olson Plumbing and Heating leveraged Viega ProPress to take on a mountain of a project: building a new visitor’s complex at the summit of Pikes Peak that met strict environmental standards … during the COVID-19 pandemic. “We prefabbed all the domestic and hydronic piping, as much as we could, to minimize labor at the top,” said Josh Crippen, superintendent at Olson. “We prefabbed our pump skids, all the water heater and boiler skids, all the waste and vent piping. As much as possible.”…
The Manufacturer/Supplier Training area of MCAA’s website connects our contractor members with training opportunities available from the members of MCAA’s Manufacturer/Supplier Council.…

MCAA’s Safety Statistics & Awards program rewards MCAA members’ safety performance. All applicants receive a valuable benchmarking report. Those who qualify also receive a certificate of commendation. Applications are due March 15, 2023. Apply today!


The Construction Employers of America will host the 2023 National Issues Conference, May 2-4, in Washington, DC. The conference will host regulators and Congress representatives for their expertise and insight on various topics. Learn more and register at http://ow.ly/EHb950MH3zC.

Looking for the latest from @uponor and Morris Group International? Find it in MCAA’s Virtual Trade Show!


Top-notch PMs with 3+ years of experience will hone their skills in planning, scheduling, change order negotiation, job cost control, and a whole lot more at MCAA's Institute for Project Management. Click the link to learn more and sign up your PMs.


Load More...