Report Shows That Union Contractors Add Value, Reduce Project Costs, Mitigate Project Risks

October 28, 2022

A new report by Independent Project Analysis (IPA), an independent international construction project engineering and research firm, shows that union mechanical contractors were 15% more productive than non-union contractors, with a more than 40% reduction in risks of cost and schedule overruns. It further reveals that the total cost of union projects was 4% less than non-union projects. The report is based on an analysis of 1,550 capital projects on industrial facilities across the United States over the past 20 years.

The United Association of Union Plumbers and Pipefitters (UA) and Mechanical Contractors Association of America (MCAA) joint press release on the topic provides additional details and project background.

The report was included as an attachment to MCAA’s comments on FAR Case 2022-003, Federal Acquisition Regulation: Use of Project Labor Agreements (PLAs) for Federal Construction Projects. Read those comments here.

You can download the full report, including methodology, here.

Related Articles
If plumbing service is a core part of your business—or needs to be—this is where you need to be. The PCA Plumbing Service Conference brings together forward-thinking contractors and service leaders for two and a half focused days of practical learning, real conversations, and strategies you can put to work immediately. Join us May 4 – 6, 2026, in Indianapolis, IN. Register now!…
The spring 2026 MSCA classes are on the calendar and open for registration. MSCA provides focused training programs for your operational personnel. This collection of programs, unlike any other, provide the continued training to set your employees apart in the HVACR industry.…
Women in Construction Week is an important opportunity to celebrate and recognize the invaluable contributions of women in the construction industry. This week highlights their achievements, honors their dedication, and inspires future generations to pursue careers in the field. Today, we celebrate the Dallas WIMI planning group, an example of how women supporting women can spark meaningful change, foster belonging, and inspire the next generation of leaders.…
Technology and innovation are evolving rapidly, and it is critical that field leaders be educated to keep pace. MCAA’s Field Leaders Conference lets field leaders explore the latest offerings from members of MCAA’s Manufacturer/Supplier Council. By asking questions, field leaders gain a fresh understanding of how those offerings impact project performance. They return ready to share these insights to help maximize your company’s ROI. That’s just one example of how the industry-specific content gives field leaders the skills, understanding, and inspiration to positively impact their company’s bottom line. Your lead field personnel cannot afford to miss this conference! Register them today!…