New Study Compares Contractor Usage of Best and Worst Language in Contract Clauses

November 7, 2022

The John R. Gentille Foundation (JRGF) has partnered with ELECTRI International (NECA) and the New Horizons Foundation (SMACNA) to assess and produce a detailed report on construction contracting best practices. Our collaboration is meant to provide industry-wide data that supports our members’ contract negotiations and guidance on better contract language to reduce liability. With better practices in place, risk can be shifted away from trade contractors to the appropriate party, leading to a more profitable industry overall.

First, Document Crunch identified the criteria used to analyze where the provisions at issue were considered Best Practice, Medium Practice, or Deficient Practice. Once those parameters were established, the Document Crunch proprietary platform extracted specific terms from each of the contracts to determine the frequency of each practice. After analyzing the data, Document Crunch has identified the 10 riskiest contract provisions that impact trade contractors.

Download a free copy of the research results below, which includes a description of each provision at issue, the criteria used to identify each issue, and the frequency of occurrence across the sample data.

The John R. Gentille Foundation underwrites the development of practices, tools, methods and materials to advance the mechanical and service trades.

Related Articles
After a January winter storm forced a last-minute reschedule, 39 dedicated industry professionals had waited two extra months to finally join us in Austin, TX. We hope that for this year’s AIPM students, last week was worth the wait! We are grateful for all the enthusiasm and energy they brought to the classroom – a critical component to making MCAA’s Advanced Institute for Project Management (AIPM) a memorable and impactful learning experience. So, to AIPM Class 22: thank you – and congratulations!…
The student chapter members at Virginia Tech proudly nominated Jonathan Bluey for the MCAA 2025-2026 Educator of the Year award based on his mentoring, mechanical industry knowledge, participation in chapter activities, and involvement in the creation of student-focused networking opportunities and collaboration with local MCA of Metropolitan Washington contractor members. In addition to a trophy, he received a $5,000 award during the MCAA26 Awards of Excellence Breakfast on Wednesday, March 18th in Phoenix, AZ.…
California State University, Chico was awarded the 2025-2026 MCAA Student Chapter of the Year award for their continued achievement and overall focus on offering career opportunities in mechanical contracting to their student membership. The award was presented at the MCAA26 Awards of Excellence Breakfast on March 18th in Phoenix, AZ.…
At the MCAA26 Awards of Excellence Breakfast on March 18th, Indiana State University was awarded the top prize of $10,000, sponsored by DEWALT, and a 1st Place trophy for their outstanding work on the 2025-2026 MCAA Student Chapter Competition.…