UA & MCAA Comment on Proposed DOL National Apprenticeship System Enhancements

March 19, 2024

The UA and MCAA recently submitted comments on the U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) proposed enhancements to the national apprenticeship system. The UA and MCAA strongly support provisions in the rule which will bolster successful registered apprenticeship programs and the safety and welfare of apprentices.

The UA and MCAA strongly support provisions in the rule which will bolster successful registered apprenticeship programs and the safety and welfare of apprentices:

  • Proposed minimum requirements of 2,000 hours of on-the-job training (OJT) and 144 hours of related instruction for every 2,000 hours of OJT.
  • Proposed changes that give the DOL the sole authority to determine which occupations are suitable for registered apprenticeship.
  • Stronger reporting and enforcement provisions for registered apprenticeship programs.

At the same time, the organizations oppose certain provisions of the proposed rule, stating that:

  • Exemptions from the requirements of 29 CFR Part 29 should not be allowed
  • National occupational standards are unnecessary and would be harmful to registered apprenticeship programs in the plumbing and mechanical trades
  • National program standards should continue to be required to comply with local requirements
  • The UA and MCAA oppose the creation of CTE (career and technical education) apprenticeships
  • The proposed rule’s prohibition on non-compete agreements is overly broad and will negatively impact valuable scholarship loan agreements
  • The definition of pre-apprenticeship program should clarify that the hands-on training component is voluntary
  • The definition of journeyworker should not be changed

MCAA Government Affairs Committee Chair Jim Gaffney noted that, “Ensuring and supporting top-tier training in the construction industry is more important now than ever, given the massive investments being made to the nation’s infrastructure and manufacturing capabilities.”

Related Articles
In Part 2 of the Construction Helmet Research Program video series, we take a closer look at the partnership behind the data.…
U.S. union membership remained essentially unchanged in 2025, with 10.0 percent of wage and salary workers belonging to a union, according to data released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). The total number of union members stood at 14.7 million, well below the 17.7 million recorded in 1983, the first year of comparable data.…
Service leaders may lack clear, data‑backed insight into whether their operations, pricing, staffing, and technology choices are competitive—causing missed revenue, weaker margins, and inefficient growth decisions. The MSCA 2025 Benchmark Survey provides valuable insight into key performance indicators (KPIs), business practices, sales, and trends across the mechanical service industry. This is one of the most powerful tools available to see how your company compares, identify growth opportunities, and guide future planning. It’s just one of MCAA’s educational resources that are free to MCAA members as a benefit of membership.…
If you want to fast-track your new and aspiring field leaders, MCAA has just the program! Once a week for 8 weeks, FFL students spend 90 minutes online with an experienced field leader, who will walk them through best practices and practical strategies of running work and running a crew. From Planning to Leadership, from Documentation to Safety: our instructors break down the ‘why’ and the ‘how’ of things that every foreman must understand to be successful.…